Who pays the broker?
It depends on who hired them. Since June 11, 2025, New York City's FARE Act says:
- If the broker works for the landlord, the landlord pays. That includes the broker who posted the listing.
- If you hire a broker yourself, you pay them.
- Nobody can make you hire a broker to see or rent an apartment.
- A broker can advertise their services to renters, but can't make you hire them to see a specific apartment.
So you can search on your own, contact the broker on each listing and pay no broker fee. More on who pays the broker fee.
What does a broker I hire actually do?
A broker you hire is your agent. New York's disclosure form calls this a tenant's agent. Their job is to get you an apartment at a rent and on terms you accept. They owe you loyalty, confidentiality and full disclosure, and they don't represent the landlord.
The broker on a listing is the landlord's agent. They have to deal with you honestly and tell you what they know about problems with the apartment. But they work to get the landlord a tenant on the landlord's terms.
Some brokers work for both sides. That's only allowed if you and the landlord both agree in writing, and the broker can't give either side full loyalty.
Anything else a broker you hire does is set by your agreement. Before you sign, ask them to list the work, such as:
- Finding apartments that fit your budget and the area you want.
- Booking and going to viewings.
- Checking your application before it goes in.
- Negotiating the rent, move-in date or lease terms.
How much does a broker I hire cost?
Whatever you agree to. New York's Department of State says broker commissions aren't set by law, so the fee is open to negotiation.
For a sense of scale, the City Council said in 2024 that broker fees ranged from one month's rent to as much as 15% of a year's rent. On a $4,000 apartment, that's $4,000 to $7,200. That describes fees renters paid before the FARE Act. A broker you hire today can charge more or less.
Get the fee in writing before they start. It should say how much, when you owe it and whether you still owe it if you find the apartment yourself.
How do searching myself, hiring a broker and using Stoop compare?
| Search yourself | Hire your own broker | Use Stoop | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Broker fee | $0. The listing broker is paid by the landlord. | What you agree to. No legal cap. | $0. Ari deals with the listing broker, who is paid by the landlord. |
| Who the broker works for | The landlord | You | The landlord. Ari works for you. |
| Finding listings | You | The broker, plus you if you want | Ari |
| Booking viewings | You, with each listing broker | Your broker | Ari |
| Negotiating rent and terms | You | Your broker, on your side | You |
| Checking the building | You | You, or your broker if it's in your agreement | You |
| Up-front costs | First month, a deposit of up to one month, up to $20 for the check | The same, plus your broker's fee | The same as searching yourself. Early access to Stoop is free. |
Stoop is our app. Ari is the AI in it: it finds places, messages the brokers, asks your questions and books the viewings. Brokers are told Ari is an AI. It doesn't negotiate or go to viewings for you. Get early access.
When is hiring a broker worth it?
You're moving from out of town
If you can't get to viewings, someone you trust has to see the apartment for you. A broker you hire can go, take video and tell you what's wrong with it.
You have very little time
If you need to sign in a week or two, a broker can line up viewings for you while you work.
The apartment is in a condo or co-op
When an owner rents out their own unit, the building may have its own application and approval on top of the landlord's. Ask about this first. A broker who has done these applications before can help you get the paperwork right.
When is it not worth it?
- You have a few weeks and can go to viewings yourself.
- The apartments you like are already listed online. The landlord's broker will show them to you for free.
- Your budget is tight. A fee of a month's rent or more comes on top of the first month and the deposit.
How do I find an apartment without a broker?
1Set your budget
Work out the rent you can carry before you look. Try the rent calculator.
2Search more than one site
No single site has every apartment. Here is how the main listing sites compare.
3Text the broker before you go
Ask whether it's still available, who pays the broker and what the move-in costs are. The questions to text first.
4Check the building
Look the address up in the city's free records before you apply. How to check a building.
5Apply with your own credit report
Applying can cost at most $20, and nothing if you bring your own check from the last 30 days. The application fee limit.
How do I check a broker's license?
Use the New York Department of State's free Public License Search on eAccessNY. Search by name or license number. It shows the license type, whether it's current and when it expires.
A broker also needs the owner's permission to advertise an apartment for rent.
What should I text a broker before I hire them?
Hi, before I hire you, can you send me your fee in writing, what you'll do for it and when I'd owe it? Will you work only for me, or also for the landlord on any apartment you show me? Thanks.
This is general information, not legal advice.
Sources
- NYC DCWP, FARE Act FAQ: effective June 11, 2025; landlord's agents and listing agents can't charge tenants; nobody can require a tenant to hire a broker; tenants may hire and pay their own broker; tenant brokers can't condition specific units on being hired
- NY Department of State, Disclosure Form for Landlord and Tenant (DOS-1735): duties of a tenant's agent and a landlord's agent; what a landlord's agent must disclose to a tenant; dual agency needs written consent and limits loyalty
- NY Department of State, Real Estate Broker FAQ: commissions aren't regulated by statute or regulation; brokers need the owner's authorization to offer a property for lease; how the eAccessNY Public License Search works
- NYC Council, November 13, 2024 vote on Int. 360-A: broker fees ranged from one month's rent to as much as 15% of the annual rent
- NY Real Property Law section 238-a: $20 or actual cost cap on background and credit checks; 30-day report waiver
- NY General Obligations Law section 7-108: security deposit capped at one month's rent