Is there an official cutoff?
No. No New York law or city rule sets a credit score you need to rent. Each landlord or management company picks its own number, and some don't publish it.
What people in the business say:
- A Corcoran broker told Brick Underground that most landlords look for a score around 700.
- Another Corcoran agent told Brick Underground that 675 or lower may raise red flags.
- A 2023 Brick Underground guide puts the usual minimum at 675 to 700.
- Insurent, a guarantor company, describes a 630 score as below what landlords usually want, which is above 700.
Treat these as rough guides, not rules. The only number that counts is the one the building uses, so ask before you apply.
What do landlords look at besides the score?
- Income. Most want your yearly income to be 40 times the monthly rent. See what that means for your budget.
- Payment history. Whether you have paid your bills on time.
- Collections. A collection account stays on your report for seven years from the first missed payment, even after you pay it.
- How much you owe. Brick Underground suggests paying card balances down before you apply.
- Paperwork. Usually pay stubs or a job letter, bank statements, tax returns and ID.
Can a landlord turn me down for a past housing court case?
No. Since 2019, New York law says a landlord can't refuse to rent to you because you were in a past or pending case with a landlord in housing court.
If a landlord checks court records or a tenant screening list and then turns you down, the law presumes they broke this rule. The landlord can try to show otherwise. The state Attorney General enforces it, with fines of $500 to $1,000 per violation.
Do old paid collections still count?
It depends on which score the landlord uses.
- FICO Score 9 and FICO Score 10 ignore collections reported as paid in full.
- VantageScore models since 2013 ignore paid collections.
- Older FICO versions can still count a paid collection. FICO 8 skips only collections that started under $100.
- Paid medical collections don't count in any version of the FICO Score.
You usually can't choose the score a landlord pulls. Ask the broker which one they use if it matters to you.
What if my credit is thin or low?
- Apply with a co-applicant. If you're renting with a partner or roommate, your incomes are added together. A co-applicant with strong credit helps, but ask whether the landlord looks at each person's score or the stronger one.
- Use a guarantor. This is someone who agrees to pay if you don't. Brick Underground reports that landlords usually want a guarantor to earn 80 times the monthly rent and have a score of at least 700. Some also want the guarantor to live in New York or nearby.
- Use a guarantor company. More on these below. Ask first, because not every building accepts them.
- Show savings. A Corcoran agent told Brick Underground that substantial savings can help. Bring recent bank or brokerage statements.
How do guarantor companies work?
You pay a company a fee, and it signs on as your guarantor. Two that are common in New York:
- Insurent. For US renters, it asks for income of at least 27.5 times the monthly rent, or cash and publicly traded investments of at least 50 times the monthly rent, plus decent to good credit. It says it can't help renters with very bad credit. The fee is about 70% to 90% of one month's rent for a one-year lease, paid before you sign. So $200,000 in a brokerage account would meet its asset test for rent up to $4,000.
- TheGuarantors. It doesn't publish a minimum score or income. Its price depends on the rent and your finances. It runs a soft credit check that doesn't affect your score. The fee is non-refundable, apart from limited cases where the lease is canceled before move-in.
Check the company's current terms before you apply, and confirm the building accepts it.
What can't a landlord ask for?
- More than one month's deposit. New York caps any deposit or advance at one month's rent. That includes prepaid rent beyond the first month. A landlord can't ask for extra months because of your credit.
- More than $20 to apply. That covers the background and credit check together. If it costs them less, you pay less. Here's the full rule.
- Another credit check fee, if you bring your own. Give them a background or credit check from the last 30 days and they have to waive the fee.
The deposit cap has exceptions for seasonal rentals and owner-occupied co-op apartments. Most regular rentals are covered.
What if I'm paying with a voucher?
In New York City, a landlord or broker can't refuse you because you're paying with a housing voucher or other rental assistance. The city's Commission on Human Rights gives a minimum credit score as an example of what this kind of refusal can sound like. Small owner-occupied buildings and units that aren't publicly advertised can be exempt.
If you think you were turned away for this, call 311 and say "Human Rights."
How do I check my credit before applying?
- Get your reports. AnnualCreditReport.com gives free reports from Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. You can check each one once a week for free. Look at all three, because they can differ.
- Dispute errors. Write to the credit bureau and to the company that reported the item. Say what is wrong and why, and include copies of your documents. The company that reported it generally has 30 days to look into it.
- Start early. A dispute can take about a month, so check before you start looking.
What if I'm turned down because of a screening report?
The landlord has to tell you, and give you the name and contact details of the company that made the report. The same goes if they ask you for a co-signer or a higher deposit or rent because of it.
You can get a free copy of that report if you ask the company within 60 days. If something on it is wrong, dispute it with that company.
What should I text the broker before applying?
Hi, before I apply, what are the landlord's income and credit score requirements for this apartment? Do they accept guarantors or guarantor companies like Insurent or TheGuarantors? Thanks.
Hi, I'm applying with a co-applicant. Does the landlord look at each of our credit scores, or our combined income and the stronger score? Thanks.
Hi, my score is around 700 with an old collection that's paid off. I can show bank and brokerage statements. Would the landlord consider that? Thanks.
Hi, I can send my own credit report from the last 30 days so I don't need to pay for a check. Does that work? Thanks.
If you're working with a broker, ask these before you pay anything. Not sure you need a broker?
This is general information, not legal or financial advice. Each landlord sets its own credit rules, so ask before you apply.
Sources
- Brick Underground, Ways to get around the 40x income requirement: a Corcoran broker on landlords looking for a score around 700, guarantors needing about 80 times the rent and a 700 score, some landlords wanting a local guarantor, and institutional guarantors
- Brick Underground, Renting with bad credit in NYC (November 2022): a Corcoran agent on 675 or lower raising red flags and savings helping, and extra deposits or upfront rent as workarounds being illegal since 2019
- Brick Underground, What to do before you start looking (January 2023): a minimum score range of 675 to 700 at most NYC landlords, what landlords look at on a credit report, and the paperwork they ask for
- Insurent, Renters: a 630 score described as below the usual landlord bar of above 700, the 27.5 times income or 50 times assets requirement, decent to good credit, and the 70% to 90% of one month's rent fee for US renters
- TheGuarantors, Renter FAQ: personalized pricing, soft credit check, and the non-refundable premium
- NY Real Property Law § 227-f: no refusing to rent because of a past or pending housing court case, the presumption when court records or screening lists are checked, and the $500 to $1,000 penalties
- NY Real Property Law § 238-a: the $20 or actual-cost cap on background and credit checks, and the 30-day report waiver
- NY General Obligations Law § 7-108: the one-month cap on any deposit or advance, and the seasonal and owner-occupied co-op exceptions
- NYC Commission on Human Rights, Source of income discrimination: voucher refusals are illegal, a minimum credit score as an example, the exemptions, and how to report
- myFICO, How collections affect your credit: paid collections ignored by FICO 9 and 10, the FICO 8 under-$100 rule, paid medical collections, and the seven-year rule
- VantageScore, Changes to medical collection reporting: VantageScore models since 2013 ignore paid collections
- FTC, Free credit reports: free weekly reports from all three bureaus at AnnualCreditReport.com
- CFPB, How do I dispute an error on my credit report?: disputing in writing with the bureau and the company that reported it, and the 30-day investigation window
- CFPB, What to do if a tenant screening report gets you denied: the denial notice, the free report within 60 days, disputes, and co-signer or higher deposit requests counting as adverse actions