The questions to text first
1Is it still available, and can I see it this week?
Hi, is the apartment at [address, unit] still available? When could I see it?
Good listings in New York go in a day or two, and some brokers keep a rented place up because it brings in calls. Ask before you travel. A good answer names the unit and gives you a time. A bad one is "come by and I'll show you a few similar ones."
2Who pays the broker fee?
Are you working for the landlord? Will I owe any broker fee?
Since June 11, 2025, a city law called the FARE Act says a broker who works for the landlord, including the agent on the listing, can't charge you a fee. You pay a broker only if you hired one yourself. A broker also can't make you hire them just to see or rent the place.
Good answer: "No fee, I represent the landlord." Bad answer: being asked to sign an agreement before you can see a place they are advertising. If a fee turns up anyway, you can report it to the city through 311.
3What is the total I need to move in?
Can you send me every cost due at signing? First month, deposit, and any other fees.
Listings have to show every fee you'd pay, and you have to get a written list of all fees before you sign the lease. The security deposit can't be more than one month's rent, so a landlord can't ask for last month's rent on top of it.
A good answer is first month's rent, a deposit of up to one month, and the check fee below. State law generally bars other fees at or before the start of a lease, so ask what allows any "holding" or "admin" fee.
4What is the application fee?
What is the application fee, and what does it cover?
State law caps the credit and background check fee at $20 or its actual cost, whichever is lower. The landlord has to give you a copy of the check and the invoice, and must waive the fee if you bring your own check from the last 30 days. Anything above $20 called an "application fee" is a bad answer.
5Is the listed rent gross or net effective?
Is $[price] the actual monthly rent, or net effective after free months?
Net effective rent spreads a free month or two across the year. A $3,600 listing with one month free on a 12-month lease is really about $3,927 a month on the lease, and renewals are often priced from that higher number. Ask for the lease number.
6Are the photos of this exact unit?
Are the photos of this exact unit, or a similar one in the building?
Model-unit photos and heavy editing are common. "Same layout, different floor" can mean a different view and an older renovation. A good answer is yes, or a short video taken today.
7Is it rent stabilized?
Is this unit rent stabilized? Will the lease include the rent stabilization rider?
A stabilized rent can only go up by a small amount the city sets each year, and you have the right to renew. Most stabilized apartments are in buildings with six or more units built before 1974. A stabilized lease comes with extra pages called the rent stabilization rider, and the rent is often an odd number like $2,186.43. You can't pull the rent history for a place you don't live in yet, so ask.
8What do I need to qualify?
What income does the landlord require, and do they accept a guarantor or a guarantor company?
Many landlords ask for yearly income of about 40 times the monthly rent, or a guarantor earning around 80 times. That is common practice. No law requires it, and it varies by landlord. If you fall short, ask what they accept instead, such as a guarantor company or proof of savings. Learn that now, before you apply.
Also worth asking
- Earliest move-in date and lease length.
- Which floor, and is there an elevator?
- Laundry in the unit, in the building, or none?
- Are heat and hot water included, or is heat on your electric bill?
- Pets allowed, and is there a pet fee or size limit?
What to check in person
A broker cannot answer these by text, and some will not tell you even if they can.
- Run the hot water in the kitchen and bathroom and time how long it takes. City rules require hot water at 120°F all year.
- Look at the radiators or heating units and ask the super who controls the heat. From October 1 to May 31, landlords must keep apartments at 68°F during the day when it is below 55°F outside, and 62°F overnight.
- Check water pressure in the shower with the sink running.
- Look under the sink and in cabinets for droppings or traps.
- Stand in the bedroom with the windows closed and listen to the street, the elevator and the neighbors.
- Check your phone signal in each room.
- Make sure the unit number on the door matches the listing.
- Talk to anyone in the lobby or hallway. Ask how the heat was last winter.
One message to send
Copy this, fill in the brackets, and send it before you book anything.
Hi, I'm interested in [address, unit] listed at $[price]. Before I come see it: 1. Is it still available, and when can I view it this week? 2. Are you working for the landlord, and will I owe any broker fee? 3. What is the full amount due at signing (first month, deposit, any other fees)? 4. Is $[price] the gross rent on the lease or net effective? 5. Are the photos of this exact unit? 6. Is it rent stabilized? 7. What income or guarantor requirements does the landlord have? 8. Earliest move-in date and lease length? Thanks!
This page is general information, not legal advice.
Sources
- NYC DCWP, FARE Act FAQ: effective date, landlord's agent cannot charge tenants, fee disclosure rules, how to complain
- NY Real Property Law § 238-a: $20 or actual cost cap on background and credit check fees, 30-day waiver, ban on other up-front fees
- NY General Obligations Law § 7-108: security deposit capped at one month's rent
- NY Attorney General, Residential Tenants' Rights Guide: $20 check fee with copy and invoice, no last month's rent on top of deposit, stabilization lease rider and renewals
- NY HCR, Fact Sheet #1: Rent Stabilization and Rent Control: which buildings are generally covered, one- or two-year renewals
- NYC, Rent Stabilization: odd-cents rent hint, how to request a rent history, who can request it
- NYC HPD, Heat and Hot Water: heat season dates, 68°F and 62°F minimums, 120°F hot water year round