What does the $20 cover?
A background check and a credit check. $20 is the total for both, not $20 each. If the check costs the landlord less, you pay less.
This is New York State law, so it applies everywhere in the state, and it applies to brokers as well as landlords. Anything else charged just for applying is illegal, whatever it's called: application fee, processing fee, admin fee.
Do I have to pay if I already have a credit report?
No. Give them a background or credit check from the last 30 days and they have to waive the fee.
If you do pay, you're owed a copy of the report and the receipt from the company that ran it. Ask for both.
Are there exceptions?
A few. A co-op can charge more when you're buying into the building. Some senior and assisted-living housing is also exempt.
Renting an apartment in a condo or co-op building from its owner is less clear. Ask for any building fees in writing before you pay, and ask who is charging them.
What else can they ask for up front?
- First month's rent.
- A security deposit of up to one month's rent, with no last month's rent on top. You get it back within 14 days of moving out, with a list of anything they kept.
A deposit "to hold the apartment" before you sign is a red flag. The law doesn't list it as something a landlord can charge.
In New York City, a broker who works for the landlord also can't charge you a broker fee, and every fee has to be shown in the listing.
What are the usual tricks?
- Charging $20 for the background check and another $20 for the credit check.
- A "processing" or "admin" fee under a different name.
- An application website that charges more than $20.
- A "move-in" or "key" fee at signing.
How do I get my money back?
Start in writing. Text or email the broker or landlord, say New York caps this at $20, list what you paid and ask for it back. Keep the receipt, the listing and every message.
If that doesn't work, file a complaint. It's free.
- The New York Attorney General, for problems with rental applications.
- The New York Department of State, which licenses brokers and can discipline them.
- In the city, the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, for broker fees and fees that weren't in the listing.
What should I text the broker before applying?
Hi, before I apply, what are all the fees to apply and at signing? I can send my own credit report from the last 30 days. Thanks.
This is general information, not legal advice.
Sources
- NY Real Property Law § 238-a: the $20 or actual-cost cap, the ban on other application and pre-tenancy fees, the 30-day report waiver, the copy and receipt rule, and the co-op and senior housing exceptions
- NY General Obligations Law § 7-108: the one-month cap on any deposit or advance and the 14-day return rule
- NY Attorney General, Tenants' rights: one-month deposit limit and no last month's rent on top of a deposit
- NY Attorney General, Housing and real estate complaint form: where to report rental application problems
- NY Department of State, September 13, 2019 guidance announcement: the $20 cap applies to licensed brokers and salespeople, and rent-regulated tenants can seek relief through HCR
- NY Department of State, Licensing complaint resolution process: how complaints against licensed brokers are handled
- NYC DCWP, FARE Act FAQ: landlord's brokers can't charge tenants, fees must be disclosed in listings and in a signed itemized list
- NYC DCWP complaint form: where to report broker fee and fee disclosure violations