What's the rule?
New York City's FARE Act took effect on June 11, 2025. It says:
- If the broker works for the landlord, the landlord pays them. They can't charge you.
- If a broker posted the listing, the law assumes they work for the landlord.
- Nobody can make you hire a broker to see or rent an apartment.
So when do I pay a broker?
Only when you went out and hired one yourself to find you a place.
If you found a listing on StreetEasy, messaged the agent on it and they showed you the apartment, that's the landlord's broker. You owe them nothing.
What can I still be charged?
Before you move in, only these:
- First month's rent.
- A security deposit of up to one month's rent. The landlord can't also ask for last month's rent.
- Up to $20 for a background and credit check. Bring your own from the last 30 days and it's free.
- A fee to your own broker, if you hired one.
Application fees and processing fees aren't allowed. Every listing has to show any fee you'd pay, and you have to get a written list of all fees before you sign the lease.
How do brokers try to get around it?
They rename the fee
A "finder's fee" or "real estate fee" is still a broker fee. Ask in writing what it's for, and don't pay it.
"You hired me"
A broker asks you to sign an agreement right before a showing, or says later that you agreed to pay on a call. If you found them through their listing, they work for the landlord. Don't sign anything that commits you to a fee just to see an apartment, and save every message.
"That one's gone, but I have others"
The apartment in the ad is suddenly rented, and the other places come with a fee. Making you hire them to get an apartment is against the law. Screenshot the original listing before it disappears.
The fee shows up in the rent
This one is legal. The law doesn't limit what a landlord asks for rent, so some raise the rent to cover the broker. Compare the rent with similar places nearby.
How do I report an illegal broker fee?
File a complaint with the city through 311's broker fees page. Include your email, or the city treats it as a tip and won't follow up. Attach texts, screenshots, receipts and the broker's name.
The city can fine a broker up to $1,000 the first time and up to $2,000 after that, and it can order your money paid back. By February 2026 it had received more than 1,400 complaints.
Is the FARE Act still in effect?
Yes. The real estate industry sued to stop it and lost. A federal appeals court upheld the law on July 13, 2026. One smaller claim about older broker contracts is still in court, but the law applies to any apartment you rent today.
What should I text a broker before a viewing?
Ask before you go, so the answer is in writing.
Hi, I'm interested in the apartment at [address]. Before I come see it, can you confirm I won't be charged a broker fee? Thanks.
If the reply is vague or mentions a fee, you have it in writing.
This is general information, not legal advice.
Sources
- NYC DCWP, FARE Act FAQ: effective June 11, 2025; who cannot charge fees; dual agents; tenant brokers cannot condition units on being hired; disclosure; enforcement through OATH; private lawsuit
- NYC Council, Int. 360-A (Local Law 119 of 2024): enacted law text, definition of fee, presumption about listings, landlord liability, penalty amounts
- NYC311, Broker Fees: how to file a complaint and why to include contact details
- NY Real Property Law section 238-a: ban on application fees; $20 or actual cost cap on background and credit checks; report, receipt and 30-day waiver
- NY General Obligations Law section 7-108: security deposit capped at one month's rent
- NY Attorney General, Residential Tenants' Rights Guide: one-month deposit limit; no last month's rent on top of a deposit; $20 check fee rules
- US Court of Appeals, Second Circuit, REBNY v. City of New York, No. 25-1506: decided July 13, 2026; affirmed; Contracts Clause claim survived dismissal in district court; landlords can recover costs through rent
- NYC DCWP, Fee Free February recap (February 27, 2026): over 1,400 broker fee complaints and 50 summonses