stoopAll guides
NYC renter guides

StreetEasy vs Zillow vs Apartments.com: which is best for NYC rentals?

No single site has every apartment, so use two or three. Pair StreetEasy, which is built around New York City, with a national site like Zillow or Apartments.com. The rules on fees are the same wherever you find the listing.

Checked against company pages, SEC filings and city sources on November 13, 2026

A corner building at night in New York
8places to search, compared
$0broker fee on any listing a broker posted
$5what Craigslist charges to post an NYC apartment

Which should I use?

  • Start with two. StreetEasy for listings from New York City brokers, and Zillow or Apartments.com for buildings whose managers advertise there.
  • Add RentHop for another view. It sorts listings by how fresh and complete they are.
  • Facebook and Craigslist have listings from many different posters rather than one company. See the place before you pay anything.
  • Check the landlord's own site when you find a building you like.

How do they compare?

SiteRun byWho posts listings
StreetEasyZillow GroupNYC brokerages
ZillowZillow GroupLandlords and property managers
Apartments.comCoStar GroupOwners and property managers, plus feeds from other sites
RentHopRentHopLandlords, brokers, agents and subletters
FacebookMeta PlatformsIndividual users
Craigslistcraigslist, Inc.Posters, who pay $5 per NYC apartment
Landlord sitesThe landlord or its managerThe landlord or its manager
StoopStoop, which publishes this guideNot a listing site. Ari finds places and messages the brokers for you.

What do I pay on any of these sites?

The fee rules are the same everywhere. Under the FARE Act, a broker who posted a listing works for the landlord and can't charge you a fee. Before you sign, you can be asked for the first month's rent, a deposit of up to one month and up to $20 for a background and credit check.

You only pay a broker you hired yourself. Who pays the broker fee and whether you need a broker at all.

As for the sites themselves, Apartments.com says searching is free, RentHop's app is free, and Craigslist's fees are paid by the people posting.

What is StreetEasy good for?

StreetEasy launched in 2006 and is built around New York City. Zillow bought it in 2013 for $50 million, and it's now one of Zillow Group's brands.

When it launched its apps in 2014, it said its listings came from hundreds of New York City brokerages, and that it showed property histories.

If a broker posted the listing, they work for the landlord. Under the FARE Act you owe them nothing.

What is Zillow good for?

Zillow is a national site run by Zillow Group, which also owns StreetEasy. Landlords list on it, and managers of larger buildings pay to advertise. Zillow also has agreements to share rental listings with Realtor.com and Redfin.

On some listings you can tour, apply, sign a lease and pay rent through Zillow.

What is Apartments.com good for?

Apartments.com is run by CoStar Group. It's the main site in a network of apartment marketing sites where owners and managers show their buildings, usually for a monthly fee. It also takes feeds from other apartment sites, owners and brokers.

Its help center says it checks listings added through its own Add a Property form, but not ones that come in through third-party feeds. It also says it can't guarantee every listing is accurate. You can report a listing with the flag icon on the page.

What is RentHop good for?

RentHop says its app searches more than 100,000 rental listings posted by landlords, brokers, agents and subletters. It ranks results with its own HopScore, based on how fresh, accurate and complete each listing is and how quickly the person posting it responds.

What about Facebook Marketplace and groups?

Marketplace and Groups are part of Facebook, run by Meta Platforms. Listings come from individual users rather than one company.

Meta says it doesn't refund person-to-person or off-site payments. Don't send a deposit before you've seen the apartment and know who owns it.

What about Craigslist?

Craigslist is run by craigslist, Inc. Posting an apartment for rent in the New York City area costs the poster $5.

Its terms say it isn't responsible for what users do. As on any site, see the place before you pay.

Should I check landlords' own websites?

Yes, for buildings run by a management company. You can contact the leasing office directly.

It's also a good check. The FTC suggests seeing whether a listing also appears on the rental company's own website. For buildings with three or more apartments, HPD Online shows the registered owner and managing agent, so you can confirm the company actually runs the building. How to look up a building.

Where does Stoop fit?

Stoop is our app. The sites above show you listings. You still message each broker, ask the same questions and book each viewing yourself. Stoop does that part. Ari, the AI in the app, finds places that fit, messages the brokers, asks your questions and books the viewings. Brokers are told Ari is an AI.

Early access is free and goes by move date. Get early access.

How do I spot a fake listing?

The FTC lists these warning signs:

  • The rent is much lower than similar places nearby.
  • You're pushed to decide fast.
  • The owner can't show the apartment, often because they're away.
  • You're asked to pay by wire, gift card or crypto.
  • You're asked for your Social Security number or pay stubs before you've agreed to rent.
  • The same address is listed by someone else under a different name.

If a broker posted it, look up their license on the New York Department of State's eAccessNY Public License Search. A broker needs the owner's permission to advertise an apartment.

What should I text before a viewing?

Text to send
Hi, is the apartment at [address, unit] still available? Are you the owner, or do you work for the landlord? Can you confirm I won't be charged a broker fee? Thanks.

More questions to ask: what to text a broker before a viewing.

Sources

You don't text a single broker.

Stoop finds the apartments worth seeing, texts the brokers and books the viewings. You just show up.

Ari finds places and messages the brokers for you.

Free. Stoop isn't a broker, so there's no fee. By joining you agree to texts from Stoop. Msg and data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out.

See how Stoop works

The one message you get

Stoopnow

Saturday is set. Three viewings, starting 10:30 AM at 214 Clermont. They're in your calendar.

Get early access