Can a landlord say no pets?
Yes. In New York you can keep a pet unless your lease says you can't. If the lease bans pets and you keep one anyway, the landlord may be able to evict you.
Read the pet clause before you sign. If the broker says your cat is fine but the lease says no pets, ask for the permission in the lease or in a signed rider.
Service animals and emotional support animals are different. They are covered further down.
Can they charge a pet deposit on top of the security deposit?
New York caps any deposit or advance at one month's rent. The law doesn't mention pets.
So if the landlord already holds a full month's rent as a security deposit, an extra pet deposit is hard to square with that cap. We haven't found official guidance that says so directly. Ask for every charge in writing before you sign.
What about pet fees and monthly pet rent?
This is less settled.
- A one-time pet fee at signing. New York bars landlords from charging fees before or at the start of a lease, apart from a background and credit check of up to $20 and charges another law allows. The law doesn't name pet fees, and we haven't found a ruling on them.
- Monthly pet rent. We haven't found a New York law that sets a limit on it. If it's in the lease you sign, expect to pay it.
Either way, get the amount in writing before you apply.
What is the NYC Pet Law?
It's a city rule that protects pets kept openly. If you keep a pet openly for three months after moving in, and the landlord or their staff know about it, a no-pet clause is waived for that pet unless the landlord starts a court case within those three months.
It's enough that the landlord's agent knows, not only the landlord.
Its limits:
- It covers buildings with three or more apartments. It doesn't cover public housing.
- It doesn't protect a pet that causes damage, is a nuisance or substantially bothers other tenants.
- It protects the pet you kept openly. It doesn't let you bring in a new one.
- A landlord can't make you give up these rights in the lease.
Don't plan a move around it. It's a backstop, not permission.
What about service and emotional support animals?
Tenants who are blind or deaf can keep guide dogs or service dogs whatever the lease says. Under federal and city law, a landlord also has to make a reasonable exception to a no-pet rule for a tenant with a disability who needs the animal.
For emotional support animals, the NYC Commission on Human Rights says:
- The landlord must allow it unless that would cause undue hardship.
- No-dog rules and breed, weight and size limits don't apply to it.
- The landlord can't charge an extra deposit or pet fee, or require extra renter's insurance. You still pay for actual damage.
- If your need isn't obvious, the landlord can ask your treatment provider to confirm you have a disability and the animal helps. They can't ask what the disability is.
- They can require the animal to be on a leash in common areas, and proof of vaccination if it's a dog.
How do I get from the airport with a pet?
A taxi is the simplest. A taxi or car service driver can refuse a passenger whose animal isn't secured in a kennel case or other suitable container. With your pet in a carrier, that reason doesn't apply. Service animals don't need a container, and a driver can't refuse them.
On public transit, the MTA rules are:
- Subway and bus. Your pet must be in a bag or other container, carried in a way that doesn't annoy other riders.
- Long Island Rail Road. Your pet must be in a container that fits on your lap.
- Service animals. Different rules apply. The MTA has a separate guide.
These rules make no exception for emotional support animals, so plan on a carrier.
What does NYC require once I live here?
- A dog licence. Every dog in the city needs one from the Health Department. It's $8.50 a year if the dog is spayed or neutered, and $34 a year if not. Apply online or by mail. The tag has to be on the collar whenever the dog is out.
- Rabies shots. New York State requires every dog and cat to be vaccinated by four months old, again within a year, and then on the vaccine's schedule.
- Dog runs. To let your dog off the leash in a city park dog run, you need proof of a current licence and rabies shot.
Cats don't need a licence.
What should I ask the broker before a viewing?
Hi, I have two cats. Does the building allow cats, and is that written into the lease? Are there any pet fees, deposits or monthly pet rent? Thanks.
Hi, I have a dog, about 40 lbs. Does the building allow dogs, and are there breed or weight limits? Are there any pet fees or pet rent? Thanks.
Hi, the listing says pets case by case. What does the landlord need from me to approve my cat, and how long does it take? Thanks.
This is general information, not legal advice.
Sources
- NY Attorney General, Residential Tenant's Rights Guide: pets allowed unless the lease bans them, the NYC three-month rule and its public housing and nuisance exceptions, guide and service dogs, and reasonable exceptions to no-pet rules for tenants with disabilities
- NYC Admin Code § 27-2009.1: the Pet Law's three-month waiver, the knowledge rule, the ban on waiving it in a lease, and the damage and nuisance exceptions
- NY Multiple Dwelling Law § 4: a multiple dwelling is a building for three or more households
- NY General Obligations Law § 7-108: no deposit or advance can exceed one month's rent
- NY Real Property Law § 238-a: no fees before or at the start of a lease beyond the $20 check and charges allowed by law
- NYC Commission on Human Rights, Emotional Support Animals in Housing: no pet limits, deposits, fees or extra insurance for emotional support animals, documentation and leash rules
- NYC Mayor's Office of Animal Welfare, Service and emotional support animals: housing providers must accommodate both unless it causes undue hardship
- NYC TLC Rules, Chapter 80, § 80-20(b)(7): drivers may refuse an animal not secured in a suitable container, except service animals
- NYC 311, Animals in taxis and for-hire vehicles: kennel case or suitable container, and service animals need none
- MTA, Traveling with pets: the subway, bus and LIRR container rules
- NYC Health Department, Dog licenses: who needs one, the $8.50 and $34 fees, the collar tag rule and the dog run rule
- NY Public Health Law § 2141: rabies vaccination for dogs and cats by four months and again within a year